Set out one quarter and three dimes. Give the group a 30-cent target. Let one student hold the quarter while another decides how to finish the amount.
Round one: no nickels
The quarter leaves a five-cent gap. With only dimes in the drawer, that gap cannot be filled. Return the quarter and use three dimes. Ask students which coin had to be put back and why.
Round two: add one nickel
Keep the same target. Slip one nickel into the drawer. A quarter plus the nickel reaches 30 with two coins. The value stayed the same while the shortest solution changed.
Round three: take away a dime
Reset to one quarter and two dimes, with no nickels or pennies. There is now more than 30 cents of total value, yet no exact solution. Have the group explain why before testing it in the coin drawer.