Everyday Field Tools / Postmark dating puzzle

Date an old photo or letter

A print says September. The same portrait appears on an August contact sheet. Which date belongs to the photograph? Work through nine fictional archive cases. Each has three records and one answer the evidence supports.

Solve the first caseStudent worksheet (PDF)Teacher answer key (PDF)

The new sign

The edge of an undated shop photograph includes a freshly painted sign.

Negative sleeve
A single exposure shows the shop with the new green sign already in place.
Painter’s daybook
The old sign came down on April 5. The green sign was installed on April 6.
Receipt
On April 12 the shopkeeper received a print from this very negative.
What is the narrowest supported window for the exposure?
Read the evidence and answer

April 6–12 The sign sets the earliest possible day. The receipt shows a print already existed by April 12. Neither record picks a day within that window.

Share this unsolved case

An envelope used twice

A collector kept a note and two envelopes, but only one travelled with the original.

Note
“I wrote this the morning after the choir concert.”
Choir programme
The concert took place on December 8.
Later envelope
A collector mailed a photocopy of the note to a friend on January 12.
Which date belongs to the writing of the original note?
Read the evidence and answer

December 9 The writer gives a one-day relationship to a dated concert. The January envelope travelled with a copy.

Share this unsolved case

The unpunched ferry ticket

A ferry ticket has no date. Its serial number and printed fare survive.

Ticket
Serial 1274. Fare 8 cents. The boarding punch is empty.
Stock ledger
The printer produced serials 1200–1299 on March 4.
Fare notice
The 8-cent fare was in force March 5–18. Unused tickets stayed in stock after that.
What can the archive establish about this particular ticket?
Read the evidence and answer

It was printed on March 4. The serial belongs to a dated print run. A fare schedule describes the price, and an unpunched ticket does not establish a trip.

Share this unsolved case

The printer’s corrected map

Three sheets survive from a printer’s map of a fictional harbour.

Proof A
The inlet is labelled “Heron Bya.”
Correction slip
“Correct Bya to Bay after Proof A.”
Sheet B
The label reads “Heron Bay.” The printer identified it as a pull made from the corrected plate.
Which order is actually established?
Read the evidence and answer

Proof A came before Sheet B. The written correction points back to A. B came off the corrected plate. No record supplies either calendar date.

Share this unsolved case

The album print

A print has a laboratory date on the back. The original negative survives separately.

Family album
A copy print bears a September 14 processing stamp.
Negative register
The same portrait is visible in a contact sheet developed August 7.
Studio card
The sitter first entered this studio on July 28, and this portrait was made during one of their visits.
When could the camera exposure have happened?
Read the evidence and answer

July 28–August 7 The studio visit sets the lower bound. The exposure already existed on August 7. September dates a later print.

Share this unsolved case

Two clocks in one photograph

A station clock and a platform clock disagree in a single exposure.

Platform dial
The platform clock reads 4:10.
Booking hall dial
Through the window, the booking-hall clock reads 4:24.
Repair notebook
One clock was running 14 minutes fast. The notebook does not identify it or say whether the other showed the correct time.
Which statement can a caption make with confidence?
Read the evidence and answer

The two displayed times differ by 14 minutes. Both dials are visible. Establishing the actual local time needs independent evidence that one particular clock was accurate.

Share this unsolved case

The second performance

A visitor’s note describes a performance without giving the date.

Theatre card
This production ran on November 12, 14 and 16 only.
Stage log
The painted moon cracked after the November 12 performance. It was replaced before the November 16 performance.
Visitor’s note
“At tonight’s performance, the moon still had that crack.”
Which performance fits all three records?
Read the evidence and answer

November 14 The crack occurred after the first performance and was gone before the last. Only the middle performance remains.

Share this unsolved case

Three witnesses or one?

Three accounts give exactly the same launch date. An editor asks how many independent observations survive.

Harbour diary
A witness wrote “the boat launched on June 3” beside a sketch made that morning.
Gazette clipping
The article states that it took its date from the harbour diary.
Museum label
The label cites the Gazette as its only source for the date.
How many independent observations of the launch date are represented?
Read the evidence and answer

One Follow the citations backwards. Both later accounts lead to the same witness. Repetition adds no second observation.

Share this unsolved case

The undated field letter

A letter says the previous day was market day. Two market days fall inside the possible interval.

Field letter
“Yesterday was market day.”
Market ledger
Markets actually took place on May 3 and May 10, with no other markets in May.
Folder note
Independent evidence establishes that the letter was written between May 1 and May 15, inclusive.
What set of dates should the cataloguer retain?
Read the evidence and answer

May 4 or May 11 Add one day to each documented market. The dates between the two candidates have no support.

Share this unsolved case

Historical source evidence practice

Open PastRush on iPhone

If you worked the cases on a computer, scan this code with your iPhone camera to open the paid game in the App Store. The browser cases and printable worksheets are free.

QR code to PastRush: History Detective on the App Store
Watch PastRush in 13 seconds · Open the case.